Stop Police Carding in Toronto!

Monday, 21 September 2015

http://www.lawunion.ca/2013/carding/

Excerpt:

1. The Law Union of Ontario remains of the strong view that both the Toronto Police Service policy with respect to “carding” and the manner in which it is carried out violate the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and the Human Rights Code. […]

Recommendation 1
7. Given that the Board has had this issue before it for over one year and seems unable to respond to public concern and anger in a timely fashion, we urge the Board to direct Chief Blair to suspend the practice of “carding” until the Board reaches its conclusion with respect to whether the practice violates the Charter and Human Rights legislation.

Recommendation 2
8. In the event that the Board is unwilling to suspend “carding” until these issues have been resolved we urge the Board to forthwith direct Chief Blair to issue a standing order or directive mandating that all officers caution persons approached for the purpose of 208 carding or street checks, advising such persons that they have the right to refuse to answer questions and are free to go.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Police forces need to play by the same rules when it comes to carding, or street checks, Ontario's community safety minister said at a heated meeting on the topic in Toronto.

Hundreds showed up at the Toronto Reference Library for the final of five public consultations about the controversial practice of carding, or street checks as they're known in some parts of the GTA, on Tuesday evening. The police tactic allows officers to stop people on the street to collect information that's stored indefinitely to help with future investigations.

Toronto police will continue carding, with some changes to policy

The city's black community says the tool amounts to racial profiling and has called for it to be stopped immediately, but police have resisted. At times, frustrations boiled over with protesters yelling their demands.

Minister Yasir Naqvi didn't make any firm commitments to ending carding, but said police need to make changes to make sure there's nothing random about the practice.

"We as government stand opposed to any random or arbitrary police stop that take place for no cause or reason or without any suspicious activity," he said.

"For us, that practice must end."

Activist Desmond Cole, who has detailed his carding experiences with Toronto police, said police aren't listening to the community's demands when it comes to ending carding.

"The Toronto Police Services Board has been hearing about this from us for years and they've chosen not to end the practice of carding," Cole said.

Police Chief Mark Saunders, who at one point during the event discussed the issue at a roundtable with Cole, called the meeting "an important assessment."

Saunders said he's looking forward to the new regulations the province comes up with.

"The street check thing right now is something that definitely needs to have regulations put in place," he said.

A small but peaceful protest closed Yonge Street near the library before the event.